Bills story of playing Richard Manuels piano on the new Rooster Rag CD
Richard Manuel’s Piano
I was told Johnny Lee’s recording studio housed Richard Manuel’s
piano. Paul Barrere had suggested we make use of Johnny’s place to
record our next project. Not that I needed any persuading--Johnny’s
studio is legendary. It is a converted garage separated from his home in
the back on a quiet street in Studio City. What gives the studio a
feeling of comfort is not just the coziness of the place, it is the man
himself. The studio’s compact style and country-western art (as in Roy
Rodgers and Gene Autry) with Gunsmoke and Have Gun - Will Travel on a
television up on the back wall are a reflection of Johnny Lee and his
laid-back style. You feel like you are at home, and you are. He’s a
great engineer and a wonderful musician—he plays just about everything.
During Little Feat’s time there for the Rooster Rag sessions he sang
some amazingly soulful and sophisticated background vocal arrangements
on “Church Falling Down,” “Rag Top Down,” and “Salome”—I’d been
completely unaware of his considerable vocal abilities. Still, I was
intrigued by what the piano might sound like, what condition it was in,
and how Johnny would handle the leakage from other instruments and amps
given the tightness of the room—the piano was in the control room. We
would all be in the control room during the recording process, with the
exception of Gabe Ford, who spent his time almost directly behind the
piano through a thin wall and door in a room used for vocals and drums.
When I played the piano for the first time, all my questions were answered and then some.
“The piano damn near plays itself!” was my thinking.
Tony Braunagel, a great drummer, producer, and long time friend of
Little Feat, and I were talking about that very subject up in San
Francisco a few weeks later. I was sitting in with Tony and Johnny Lee,
along with Texacali horns Darrell Leonard and Joe Sublett (who played on
our record), for a gig with the Blues Brothers.
Tony said, “You can’t play anything on that piano that doesn’t sound good.”
I laughed, telling him I felt the same way. The truth is, it’s a
Steinway. This one in particular has the “magic” (a word I tend to use a
lot, but I always mean it). A few weeks later I called Johnny Lee and
asked him about the history of the instrument, starting with when he
first became acquainted with it.
Shangri La studios in Malibu, 1979
Johnny Lee was at Shangri La studios recording a project with Ian
McLagan, his second solo album. And although he was there to play
guitar, he would show up early just to play the piano. Johnny knew it
was Richard Manuel’s. He loved the touch and the way it sounded—always a
winning combination for a musician and an instrument. A good handshake.
The studio, which had played host to many artists over the years: Bob
Dylan, The Band, Bonnie Raitt, Tom Waits, Eric Clapton, and others, was
not too long after put up for sale, along with the gear, including the
piano. Money changed hands, the piano took a journey to Connecticut, did
an about face not too long after and headed west again, this time
landing in storage in Tarzana, CA. (Yes, Tarzana has a lineage to Edgar
Rice Burroughs character, Tarzan.) Thankfully, through a series of
maneuvers and continued changing hands, the piano eventually wound up,
through barter, with Johnny Lee Schell.
As Johnny was familiar with the instrument and had a warm place
in his heart for it, he made some repairs: replaced a couple of broken
keys and other minor fixes, and had the piano restrung. There were marks
on the inside of the sounding board where a Helpinstill pickup had been
placed—the device was used to amplify the sound at live venues. It was
something straight out of the Spanish Inquisition, not very good for the
cosmetics of the interior of the piano.
I still wanted to know what the deeper connection to Richard Manuel was. Johnny continued the story.
Vincitore’s Hudson Valley Piano Center
Somewhere between 1967 and 1969 (‘67 the year consequently that I
graduated from high school), Richard Manuel and Garth Hudson went on a
search for a piano. The quest led them to New York, Chicago, and other
places in the United States and Canada. They tried out a dozen or so
pianos in the process, according to Johnny Lee.
Based on that information, I placed a call to Garth Hudson and had a
brief conversation about what transpired. And while the details of how
it exactly went down are somewhat foggy (he wasn’t able to tell me what
other cities, if any, were visited), the search ended (or began and
ended) in Poughkeepsie, NY, at Vincitore’s Hudson Valley Piano Center.
Garth remembers the two of them going there and that Richard picked out
The Steinway Richard chose was from the “L” series, measuring
just under six feet, Steinway’s smallest concert grand—otherwise known
as a baby grand. I would imagine that one of the features Richard and
Garth were looking for was something small enough to haul around on
tour (which Garth confirmed) and, of course, possessed a wonderful tone
and touch. Apparently, they were taking it out on the road with the Band
and Bob Dylan. Crews are notorious for giving keyboard players hell for
having to tote a piano around the world, or just about anywhere, for
that matter. One can hardly blame them. (On Waiting For Columbus I
promised our crew it would be the last piano they would have to lug
around on my behalf. But I insisted on using a real piano for those
recordings.) The size of the piano nearly made for a major disaster, as
you will read later.
I was intrigued by where the instrument was finally found. Garth
had mentioned Vincitore’s, so I looked them up on the Internet. I was
more than pleasantly surprised by what I discovered.
It is a family-owned store that has been in business since 1946. I noted
from the website some of its history. Joseph Vincitore’s philosophy,
the founder of the company, still resonates today: “Enrich Your Life
Mr. Vincitore is now ninety-four and plays the clarinet and
saxophone every day—a true testament to that philosophy. His oldest son,
Jon P. Vincitore, took over managing the business in 1977. He was
twelve years of age when he first started working for the family
business. His brother, Michael J., has hands-on experience with the
technical aspects of the piano, having served an apprenticeship in his
early twenties with Daniel Mazzilli, a foreman for Steinway Pianos in
New York City. Their sister, Marta Vincitore Robinson, handles the
sheet music part of their enterprise along with the bookkeeping
responsibilities, which she does in her spare time. I called the store
and Marta answered. I told her I was interested in speaking to someone
about a piano that Richard Manuel, from The Band, bought in the late
sixties. She cheerfully put me through to her brother Michael, and we
had a wonderful conversation.
Michael, who was seventeen at the time—which would put the date at
1969--remembers three or four members of The Band coming into the
store. As they were famous musicians, this was pretty exciting. The
level of their musicianship was something Michael made note of. They
could really play. He told me his father, a graduate of Julliard, was
impressed in particular with Garth Hudson, who played the saxophone as
well as keyboards. Michael thought it was a nice piano, that he liked
it. Once the decision to buy it happened, he remembers the piano going
out for delivery.
Qualities of The Piano
My discussion with Michael ranged into the broader concepts of what
goes into the making of pianos. He told me there is something
serendipitous about Steinways. There are certainly many factors that
draw people to an instrument: tone and touch the two biggest components.
Michael is schooled in the art of regulation, which brings consistency
throughout the keyboard by controlling the factors of touch and sound,
including its dynamic range (from soft to loud), and the responsiveness
to the keys (a hard action or a light action). Does the person sitting
down at the instrument want a lighter touch--as Glenn Gould used to
demand for his work, in particular, with Bach, or a harder action so one
can dig in deeper? How about a less strident high end in the upper part
of the keyboard—the highest notes produce a “ringing sound” because of
the lack of damper (suppressing the string’s tone by means of inserting
felt between the three strings at the top of the instrument for each
note, thus the notes ring out less). You can control that and all of the
tactile and tonal qualities with regulation of the instrument.
Richard’s piano is very forgiving in its touch—it is easy to
play, and yet the sound is surprisingly deep and rich on the low end of
the sonic spectrum for an instrument under six feet. It is a very
soulful piano. I’ve never played one quite like it. Johnny Lee had made a
statement to me about its diversity in regard to the styles one could
play on it: rock & roll, ballads, and jazz, for example.
With the broad vocabulary of any Little Feat album, this was good news,
as I played a wide array of musical styles on the album, all of which
fit like a glove.
Many recording studio pianos are manipulated by technicians,
lacquering the hammers, being one method, to brighten the sound in order
to compete with raging guitars, drums, etc. This was not the case with
the piano in Johnny Lee’s studio. Richard’s piano has a softer tone that
signifies the Steinway “sound.” And although each Steinway is
different, Michael insisted to me that the standard employed in
manufacturing them is based on creating consistency. Tone and touch can
be abetted in an amazing fashion, dramatically, in some cases—thus
deviating from the standard and the model of consistency--by any trained
technician who has a sense of what the artist wants or wants to
I visited Steinway Pianos on 57th Street in New York City in the
mid-eighties with Ed Kolakowski, who was the piano tech on the James
Taylor tour I was a part of. He introduced me to Franz Mohr, the head of
Steinway’s technicians. I was taken down to the basement where I played
six or seven of their instruments. Franz casually asked me, but with a
twinkle in his eye, if I would care to play Horowitz’s piano—he had just
returned from the Soviet Union. Of course I said yes! I sat down and
played the low end of the instrument first, which had a thunderous
response. I then played the very top end of the piano. The sound was
noticeably softer, not dramatically so, but caught my attention. It was
when I hit the middle region that I looked up incredulously at Franz—the
sound was as if I had pressed the sostenuto pedal, very soft. With a
slight shrug of his shoulders and a smile he told me, “That’s the way he
likes it voiced.” I never knew how malleable a piano could be until
that day. Franz Mohr had taught me an invaluable lesson on how to view a
piano and how it might conform to my needs as an artist.
I also believe an instrument should challenge the musician,
leaving room for growth through exploration, trial and error, while
keeping an open mind and making the most of a potent imagination, all of
which form a vital link to what is literally one’s relationship with
the instrument, a relationship that can last for many, many years.
Richard Manuel was looking for and found the “handshake,” which formed
his relationship with this wonderful, and in my mind, “magic” piano.
College Girls, Hashish, & Confrontation
Enter Butch Dener into the conversation. Butch was road manager for
the Band for many years. I called him to get his take on not only the
instrument but some of the dates being tossed about. The Band played at
his high school in New Paltz, NY, before a one-off gig with Bob Dylan at
the Isle of Wight in 1969, and on Dylan’s two-month concert tour in
1974. It is more than probable that Richard was playing the Steinway
purchased from Vincitore’s. I asked Butch if he had any stories about
the piano. He led me through the following that took place in 1972. It
involves a stash house, some college girls, and a crazed hashish dealer.
The Band had some rental properties in and around Bearsville. One
of the homes, nestled down a dirt road path deep in the woods, was
sublet to four college girls who used it as a “stash house.” The girls
were “mules,” transporting drugs to the house, making inventories of
what they had, sitting on the load until things cooled off, and then
distributing the goods onto the open market. As it happened, the
Steinway was also stashed there. Richard Manuel and Rick Danko
innocently went over to look in on the piano. The girls, known as the
Screaming Mimis (no relation to the group), were working for a hashish
dealer, a dangerous character, who had at one point threatened Butch
Dener’s life in close proximity to a policeman. The girls happened to
make a call to their boss mentioning that the guys were coming over. The
dealer (who shall remain nameless) stormed over to the house in an
absolute rage. Richard and Rick were confronted with a flailing,
shouting, screaming, madman, who told them he was going to destroy the
piano. He even made an attempt—he was a black belt and strong as a
proverbial ox—to actually lift up the piano from one end and toss it on
them. Somehow they were able to talk him off the roof. He finally calmed
down as the boys were of no consequence to him or his operation. The
piano, along with Richard and Rick, lived to see another day.
In investigating this saga I will freely admit that the dates
don’t match up with some of the storytellers. Understandable given the
number of years ago the events took place.
(My friend and writer, Michael Simmons, gave me considerable help
and guidance with regard to those shifting sands, amongst his other
helpful suggestions for this article. Dennis McNally, my friend,
manager, writer and thoughtful editor, kept me on track, as well. My
heartfelt thanks to them both.)
That said, there is no doubt that Richard Manuel and Garth Hudson
traveled the short distance from Woodstock to Poughkeepsie (roughly
thirty-two miles apart) and found the instrument I played some
forty-five years later in Johnny Lee Schell’s studio for the recording
of Little Feat’s Rooster Rag.
It was a piano well chosen. I enjoyed playing it. I can’t wait to
play it again on the next studio recording. I’ve got some songs made for
Bill Payne - July 2012